Despite the relative plainness of this concoction, there’s innumerable variables that can be changed to alter the flavor of the scotch, which makes each single malt its own distinctive animal. After trying as many variations as we could lay our hands on, we decided which were the 15 best single malts, worthy of your palette, and which could be kept only for your philistine friends.
Speyburn 10 Year Old
Cheap Date: A surprising little highlander that is oaky and has a grain background, rather than being fruity like its countrymen, Aberfeldys and Obans. Outdoorsy in flavor and perfect for getting a hint of honey mixed into your sipping schedule, it’s a hell of a bargain, usually under $40. Price: $36
Balcones Texas Single Malt
Hello, Darkness: The coloration alone doesn’t conjure up the typical image of a single malt, but a deeper rye or a heavy bourbon. Along with this difference in color, it also swaps flavor palettes, opting for a load of sweetness that earned it 2012’s “Best in Glass” award. Besides the rich, complex flavor, the 53% alcohol content gives it plenty of kick. Price: $108
The Balvenie Caribbean Cask
Old Rummy: Rather than using Sherry casks to age this Caribbean offering from Balvenie, they use rum which gives each mouthful the laid-back feel of a spicy nip from a rum-runner. Unlike any scotch of any breed or brand, the cherry and brown sugar flavor isn’t for everyone, but it’s a unique, homey brew that will warm your heart’s cockles. Pricee: $53
Ardbeg Uigeadail
Tongue Twister: Open the bottle and the nose is all smoke and peat with a saltwater backing that will threaten to sweep you away. In your gullet, it drops the hammer like any quality non chill-filtered Islay, but add some water and you’ll get more of the sweet sherry backing and playful toffee. Price: $64
Balblair 1999
Distiller’s Choice: Selected specifically by the manager of Balblair, John MacDonald, the 1999 is a quick double-action whiskey that’s spicy and sweet with leather, honey, and vanilla all making appearances on the tongue. Though the 46% ABV isn’t meant to knock you down, this smooth operator can get on top of you fast. Price: $73
Glenlivet Nàdurra Peated
Throwback: Borrowing heavily from Glenlivet founder George Smith’s hallowed recipe, the Nàdurra marks the first time in more than 100 years that Glenlivet offered a peated single malt, and the result is titillating. Aged in peated whiskey barrels and bottled at full cask strength, it’s not for the faint of heart, but bit of citrus and vanilla do ease the peat off the throttle. Price: $59
Highland Park Odin
Viking Proof: The sweetness that we expect from Highland Park is in full display, but this 16-year-old comes loaded for bear with a 56% alcohol content that will either wake you up or knock you cold. Peat and wet ground combine for a perfect way to pass a rainy day, even if you don’t recall all of it. Price: $216
Westland Peated American Single Malt
Name Dropper: We wouldn’t have given this a first sip if we were going off the name, which sounds like a Highland knockoff, but this is proudly from the Pacific Northwest. It’s subtle, gentle, and calm as floating atop a mountain lake with peat smoke that drifts in, as if from an open window; nary a jagged edge in sight. Price: $82
Dalwhinnie Winter’s Gold
Ice Queen: Meant to be served frozen, Winter’s Gold begins by whispering honeyed sweetness, then gradually adds in heather and spice flavors as it adjusts to room temperature and allows the warmer tastes and scents to shine through. Only made during October through March, this is a true Yuletide miracle. Price: $47
Auchentoshan Three Wood
Triple Threat: The name comes from the three different barrels that are used to age this whiskey. Beginning with American Bourbon for a bit of swagger, then onto Spanish Oloroso Sherry to add sweetness, and finishing off in Pedro Ximenez Sherry casks, the complex toffee and oak tastes are only the tip of the spear. Price: $50
Glendronach 15 Year Revival
Finishing Blow: Finished with Sherry to blunt the bite, this opens with a nose of vanilla, toffee, and pine, then a taste of fennel with peat that melts away to reveal molasses, peach, and ctirus. Sherry and smoke play tug of war for a while, then sink away, their work artfully complete. Price: $55
Bunnahabhain 18 Year Old
Supporting Actor: Bunnahabhain gets overlooked by the single malt crowd, because it is so often used in blends. Though most understudies never quite learn how to be leading material, this pulls it off nicely. From casks of sherry and bourbon, it’s riddled with wine, raisin, and grape flavors, with a nuttiness that makes the caramel and honey sing out. Price: $82
Yamazaki Single Malt Sherry Cask
Rising Sun: One of only a pair of whiskeys made at the Suntory in Japan, this cut the head off the scotch world when it beat out every Scottish whiskey that cared to step to it a couple years ago. It matures in Bordeaux barrels, giving it a strong hit of red berry flavoring that sets it apart from the crowd, with just enough oak to keep it from going over the edge. Price: $59
Bowmore 25 Year Old
Islayman Terms: Bowmore cannot be forgotten, but choosing from among their impressive array was a challenge. The nose is a standard Islay, with peat and salt and fire, but the taste is hazelnut and pecan with powerful cocoa and orange with a playful lemon zest. After a sip, chocolate crème brûlée taste lingers on the tongue. Price: $336
Port Ellen 34 year old
But Not Forgotten: A collector’s item to be sure, the Port Ellen distillery died more than 30 years ago in 1983, which explains the price tag of several thousand dollars. Cinnamon, orange, leather, and bonfire are the flavors you can expect should you lay your hands on this grail of the single malt world. Price: $2,800
